Welcome to Geno Nottolini's Pizza
Geno Nottolini's Pizza, nestled in Elgin, IL, is a beloved gem known for its hearty and delicious offerings. Patrons rave about their generously topped pizzas, with a standout being the meat lovers variety. The inviting atmosphere is complemented by friendly service from the owner, who embodies a commitment to quality. Customers appreciate the exceptional value, evidenced by deals like two slices for just $5. Beyond pizza, the catering options, such as the highly praised baked mostaccioli, make it a go-to choice for gatherings. Overall, Geno Nottolini's Pizza perfectly marries affordability with authentic Italian flavors, creating an experience that keeps diners returning.
Geno Nottolini's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Pizza is always great. Best bacon around.
We ordered a catering package (#3) plus pizza from Geno Nottolini's yesterday. Everything was absolutely perfect! From the delivery driver being right on time to the food being piping hot for our guests. So many of our guests commented on the baked mostacolli...it truly is the best around! In fact, one lady (who doesn't like mostacolli) asked to take home extras. That's also to say the beef, chicken, salad and pizza were terrific, too! If you're looking for an Italian restaurant to cater or just order from, you won't be disappointed in Geno Nottolini's.
I come here every now and then on my lunch break to get slices. The prices are crazy good (I got 2 GIANT slices and a can of soda for 6) and the food is great too. Owner is an honest guy who just needs more people comin thru the doors! Will be back for more lunch!
Saw the sign out front for 2 slices for 5, (added a soda for only 1) so I had to swing in and try it. Slices are massive and toppings are generously added. One of the best meat lovers pizza I've ever had. Owner was very friendly and the business was very clean. I look forward to stopping here often!
I stopped in on my way to my mom's and picked up the special of a slice and drink. The price was cheap(I think 5), and the slice was huge! The dough is a little thick but not heavy on the stomach. This is definitely a great, filling, cheap eat.
I tried Geno Nottolini's Pizza for the 1st time, and I was very impressed. I ordered the thin crust, extra crispy pizza, and it was made perfectly. I also had an order of the mozzarella sticks, and they were such a yummy appetizer. The gentleman who took my order over the phone was friendly and knowledgeable, and I will definitely order from here again! I highly recommend Geno Nottolini's!! A
Got a deep dish Ultimate on our way through to WI. So glad we did. The pizza is amazing. Even the next day it heats up great and is still delicious. Crust on the bottom is crispy but not overdone and the top is fluffy with tons of toppings and cheese. They were very friendly as well. Definitely give it a try
Anyone who disparages this establishment doesn’t know good, take out Italian that you’re looking for. Thin crust is also stellar that I order often. Flaky crust. But their deal on Wednesday for bogo pasta for a buck is HANDS DOWN! the best deal in town. My top two are the stuffed shells and lasagna. Even after prices were raised it’s only 14. Could be 4 meals but usually only two for me. 7 a meal? Good luck. Not for this quality. I’ve seen bay leaves in the red sauce. It’s quality scratch cooking for the best price in town! Well done
Location
-
1061 N Liberty St, Elgin, IL 60120, United States Hotline: +1 847-888-4884
Welcome to the taste sensation that is Geno Nottolini's Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Elgin, Illinois. Located at 1061 N Liberty St, this pizzeria has quickly cemented itself as a go-to destination for pizza lovers and Italian cuisine aficionados alike.
From the moment you step through the door, the warm and inviting atmosphere greets you, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience. Geno Nottolini's Pizza prides itself on serving up delicious, authentic dishes that showcase a commitment to quality and flavor.
One of the standout features of this establishment is undoubtedly the pizza. Customers rave about the generous portions and the rich, vibrant flavors. Mike N., a dedicated patron, insists that "the pizza is always great" and hails theirs as the best bacon around. This sentiment resonates with many, as the toppings are not only plentiful but also crafted with care.
But it doesn't stop at pizza. Giovanni's impressive menu boasts a variety of items, including the highly praised baked mostaccoli. As Barb Wood experienced, their catering packages are perfect for any gathering, showcasing a flawless delivery experience and dishes that keep guests coming back for more. The beef, chicken, salad, and, of course, the pizza, were all crowd-pleasers—a true testament to the kitchen's skill.
Conveniently located for those on the go, many locals like Bradley Gordon and Jake Sullivan enjoy stopping by for a quick lunch. With offers such as 2 slices for $5 and excellent meal deals, it’s hard to resist trying the massive slices loaded with toppings. And let’s not forget about the friendly and honest service from the owner, which adds a personal touch to every visit.
For those seeking affordable yet filling options, Samantha’s experience echoes that sentiment. The price is right, and the portions are generous. The dough strikes a perfect balance—not too heavy, yet satisfying after each delightful bite.
In summary, Geno Nottolini's Pizza isn't just a place to grab a meal; it's an experience that brings together delicious food and vibrant community. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or catering for an event, you can expect nothing short of perfection. Join the countless satisfied customers and discover why this pizza parlor is a beloved local favorite!